criminal investigations on taxpayers
  • June 28, 2023
  • admin
  • 0

There are many reasons why you might end up facing an Internal Revenue Service (IRS) tax investigation. Many taxpayers don’t even know they’re under investigation regarding alleged tax evasion or tax fraud until the IRS comes looking for them. There are many different kinds of tax fraud that all attract different penalties, and without proper counsel, it is easy for issues to spiral out of control. If an IRS agent comes across incriminating information during the civil audit, it can lead to an indictment or jail time in certain cases. When you understand how the IRS initiates its tax investigations, you can take preemptive measures by hiring an IRS tax problems resolution attorney to represent you. Understanding how IRS tax investigations are initiated is key.

What is the purpose of an IRS Tax Investigation?

The IRS initiates tax investigations of taxpayers that are suspected of taking part in a tax crime. Through the investigation, the IRS can gather evidence that either exonerates the subject or leads to the initiation of criminal prosecution. When an IRS tax investigation indicates wrongdoing, the consequences can be huge fines and even jail time. This is why it is important to avoid an investigation altogether or make sure that it is carefully managed. Working with a tax law attorney is crucial for your IRS problem’s resolution.

How does an IRS investigation differ from an audit?

During an audit, the IRS simply verifies that you have correctly determined your tax liability. However, when an investigation takes place, the IRS works to build a case against you in respect of your tax crimes. Evidence gathered can later be used for prosecution. An IRS tax investigation is far more serious and should be handled carefully with the help of tax law professionals, such as tax resolution attorneys.

Are you at risk of an IRS Tax investigation?

There are several reasons why the IRS might choose to investigate a taxpayer. A suspicion that any tax crime has been committed such as fraud or tax evasion is reason enough for the IRS to start gathering evidence against you. Some of the signs that you are on the IRS’s radar include having your bank records summoned, or your accountant contacted by the CID. If you have been under audit and your agent suddenly goes MIA, they might also be getting ready to pass on your case to the CID.

Related Blog: 4 Ways a Tax Lien Can Affect You

What to do if you are being investigated?

If you are already under investigation, it is important that you take action as quickly as possible. The most beneficial thing you can do is consult with a tax resolution attorney. Getting your case managed by a tax pro boosts your chances of getting the desired IRS problem resolution. You will also prevent making any mistakes that could worsen your situation. Inform your accountant about the investigation and cease communication thereafter. This is very important because, unlike attorney-client privilege, conversations with an accountant are not protected.

Who Informs the IRS of Possible Fraud?

The IRS has multiple sources of information. They include-

  • Information collected by revenue agents and revenue officers
  • Information provided by other law enforcement agencies
  • Information collected from your digital footprint
  • Discrepancies found during computer data analysis
  • Information provided by whistleblowers

What Happens with this Information?

This information is analyzed to ascertain whether tax fraud or a different financial crime is being committed. This process is called a primary investigation. After the primary investigation is over, a supervisor looks at the collected facts to determine if the findings are to be further investigated or not. If the supervisor gives his go-ahead, the case is sent to management for approval, after which a special agent begins a criminal investigation. At this point, the IRS has established they have enough evidence to start a criminal investigation.

Related Blog: Understanding the Various Types of IRS Levies

IRS Criminal Investigation Process

The Criminal Investigation Division of the Internal Revenue Service conducts criminal investigations on taxpayers if they commit tax evasion or allegedly violate the Bank Secrecy Act, the Internal Revenue Code, and various money laundering statutes. If a taxpayer has committed tax evasion, the IRS can prosecute within six years, but if they have committed tax fraud, the IRS has unlimited time to prosecute the case. In this section, we take a closer look at how the IRS initiates criminal investigations. Read on!

IRS Special Agents

Criminal investigations are initiated from information obtained from IRS revenue officers, who may sniff out cases of possible fraud. The findings and outcomes of these investigations are transferred to the Department of Justice for recommended prosecution. If taxpayers receive a notice about an IRS tax investigation, they must immediately seek assistance from a tax resolution attorney, who can communicate and negotiate with the IRS on their behalf to come up with a mutual solution.

1. Preliminary Analysis

The special agents within the IRS analyze the information obtained by IRS revenue officers to establish whether a taxpayer has committed any criminal tax fraud or financial crime. This process of evaluating all the relevant information is called a primary investigation. The special agent then transfers preliminary information to front-line supervisors, who decide if the case needs to be approved for further investigation. If the supervisor approves, the special agents initiate a subject criminal investigation. During the preliminary investigation, at least two levels of CI management review the information of ‘primary investigation’ and determine if it should go for further investigation, depending on the evidence and proof.

2. Criminal Investigation

Once the IRS special agents receive approval to carry out a criminal investigation, they start obtaining all the critical facts and evidence which can establish strong elements of criminal activity or tax violation. For this purpose, they use many investigative techniques such as executing search warrants, interviews of witnesses, subpoenaing bank records, reviewing financial data and tax filing history, and conducting surveillance. The IRS agents work with the IRS Chief Counsel Criminal Tax Attorneys and other IRS resolution attorneys so that they do not make any mistake in addressing all the legal aspects of the investigation.

3. Prosecution Recommendations

After the facts and evidence are analyzed by the IRS special agents, they will determine whether they substantiate criminal activity. In case they do not, the investigation is discontinued. If there is evidence of a criminal activity or significant tax rules violation, the agent can prepare a written ‘special agent report’ that lists the findings of law violations and recommends prosecution. The report is reviewed by supervisory special agents, a criminal investigation quality review team, and CI special agents and their assistants. All the officials decide if the case should be criminally prosecuted and forwarded to the United States Attorneys, Department of Justice, and Tax Division if it is a tax-related investigation. Once the Department of Justice and attorney accept the prosecution, the special agent will start preparing for trial. Once all the evidence is gathered, the IRS Criminal Investigation prosecution then proceeds to obtain a conviction, by either a guilty verdict or a plea.

Prevention is Better than Cure

If the IRS decides to start a criminal investigation, it means that they have enough evidence to prosecute you. With a conviction rate of 91.2%, it is safe to say that a guilty verdict is all but assured. Paying taxes on time and consulting an attorney helps ensure that you stay protected and get ahead of the IRS tax investigation.

Wrap Up

The Internal Revenue Service cannot tolerate tax violations and financial fraud and has complete authority to take action against offending taxpayers. It is, therefore, important to remain in good books with the IRS by filing your taxes on time and not getting involved in any financial activity that is considered fraudulent. In the event that you or someone you know is involved in a tax violation, you must immediately seek IRS tax help from the team of Dallas IRS tax lawyers at the Law Offices of Nick Nemeth, PLLC. Our experienced Fort Worth tax attorneys specialize in helping taxpayers get favorable outcomes to a range of IRS tax problems. To speak with one of our Dallas tax attorneys or book a free tax attorney consultation, call (972) 426-2991, or email You can also fill out our contact form.

Please follow and like us:

What Our Clients Have to Say

Brent VahleBrent Vahle
19:13 02 May 24
I called to see if they could help reduce some penalties and fees. The person I spoke with told me it might be counterproductive for them to take my case since their feels would likely equal the amount of penalty/interest abatement. I decided to pass on moving forward but was so happy to hear a legal team, or any business for that matter, who has that much integrity. I feel most others would likely try to take my money anyway. I hope I never have to go through this again, but if I do, I will definitely use the Law Offices of Nick Nemeth!
Jason WinkleJason Winkle
18:44 02 May 24
Jaime Flores was very friendly, professional, and knowledgeable. She gave me some very valuable information which helped guide me with a plan of action. The free consultation is very much appreciated.
Matthew SwigartMatthew Swigart
12:14 02 May 24
Great attorney who was able to provide quick and useful advice. Although my situation did not warrant their services, they still took the time to discuss solutions I could explore. I highly recommend visiting this office!
Tony PantojaTony Pantoja
12:57 09 Apr 24
Very professional and very knowledgeable, Jamie Flores was very straight forward and professional, a firm that doesn’t just take your money, Thanks
Carla AtwalCarla Atwal
10:52 02 Apr 24
Nick was wonderful in guiding me with direction on some tax questions I had. He was concise, and to the point, and was happy to provide general info to me at no charge. I truly appreciate him and would highly recommend him.
Miguel AlvaradoMiguel Alvarado
15:56 25 Mar 24
By far the best attorneys I have ever worked with. They’re are very helpful and supportive from day one. They went above and beyond to make sure all my documents were submitted on time and gave updates as soon as they received them. I cannot name a single flaw in their work. Their team of assistants are very professional and seem to all be on the same page. I’ve made multiple phone calls and sent a ton of emails to their staff and they were able to help me all through the course of the case. I cannot express my gratitude enough for how excellent they handled my case.
Lucy FoyLucy Foy
06:55 19 Jan 24
My first appointment I had with, Tax Attorney Nick Nemeth, gave me such a sense of relief. He listened and gave me his professional advice, Mr Nemeth took my case. I was well kept updated, by phone calls and letters. That really impressed me and gave me so much confidence in them. The case went on for a couple of months. The day I received the call from one of his team members Kyle, informing me that the case was resolved and that I owed absolutely nothing to the IRS, I was overwhelmed with joy. I would recommend this law firm to anyone that needs help, with any tax issue. Thank you, to the Law Firm of Attorney Nick Nemeth and his team.
Bradley RunyonBradley Runyon
20:17 13 Jan 24
I received a tax bill in the mail from the IRS last year in 2023. The fees and penalties I owed were something I myself could not afford. I reached out to Nick Nemeth's firm and received the best experience you could imagine. The team was professional, educational, and fast. If you have a tax issue with the IRS using another firm other than Nick Nemeth's would be an error in judgment. I would recommend their services above others.
Sue HulsemanSue Hulseman
19:55 11 Jan 24
Working with Nick Nemeth and his team to resolve my debt with the IRS was the best decision I could have made. I felt such relief knowing I didn’t have to deal with the IRS myself. They did a wonderful job and were responsive to my questions and kept me abreast of my case. My outcome was exactly what I was hoping for. I strongly recommend using them if you have an issue to resolve with the IRS.
20:53 21 Dec 23
I had an incompetent tax preparer, who also ignored several notices from the IRS, which in the end resulted in a lien on my property. I did not know what to do and an attorney friend recommended that I contact the Nick Nemeth Law Offices. I met with Jamie Flores and Ivan Nalbantov in December 2021 for a free consultation, and right away was impressed by their thorough examination of my paperwork and extensive knowledge of IRS tax laws. I felt not pressured and appreciated their advice and in the end decided that I would pursue resolving the issue by myself. I paid the IRS Civil Penalty and, as recommended also submitted a letter to the IRS requesting a refund and explaining what happened. I am glad to report that my persistence finally paid off. My case took two years to resolve and I finally received a full abatement/refund check from the IRS in December 2023. I could not have done this without the straightforward recommendation of Jamie and Ivan; and I highly recommend the Nick Nemeth Law Offices to anyone needing help with the IRS.
Susan WilsonSusan Wilson
03:27 25 Jan 23
I have been very pleased with the solid counsel and guidance that Nick Nemeth has provided me regarding my tax issue. I found him to be honest and straightforward which I appreciated. I was impressed with his relevant experience and knowledge . He has definitely brought me peace of mind during a difficult and stressful time.
Sarah HowardSarah Howard
03:44 14 Nov 22
I would like to thank Mr. Nick and his staff for the superb help that I received from them. My IRS problem was resolved quickly and efficiently. It took 2 visits to convince me that I was over my head. I thought that I could call the IRS, appeal my tax notices and settle on a payment plan on my own. After many phone calls to the IRS, waiting sometimes more than 4 hours with no resolution to speak of, it proved to be extremely difficult and stressful. Revisiting Mr. Nick was a huge wake up call. My account was reviewed, and a payment plan was established with the IRS within a week. I will be forever grateful to the staff who worked on my case and especially to Lorna who listened to me vent while going through this painful process.
00:33 07 Aug 22
I cannot say enough good things about Nick and his team. When I first met with Nick he was up front, honest, friendly and efficient. When I worked with one of his attorneys, Eric B, I was just as pleased. All of the staff there are nice and very helpful. I wish I hadn't waited so long to get help with my issue. Over 6yrs I tried getting through and getting anywhere with the IRS and hardly made any progress. I know this may not be the case for all, and even I thought it would take longer than it did, but 3mos and they had my situation straightened out. I still can't believe it. Thank you thank you THANK YOU for all that you did for me. This is a huge burden gone out of my life now thanks to you. If anyone needs help out there, I know you may not want to shell out more money to get their help but it may just save you in the long run.
Spoilly GirlSpoilly Girl
23:49 03 Aug 22
The Nemeth Law team is exceptional. They treat their clients like a family member who is in crisis. They want you to get the best possible outcome. I really appreciate everything that they did for me. Jake and Ashley had the greatest role in my case and it all turned out for the best for me. Thank you Nick and team for easing my fears and getting me through the long process. I'm truly grateful.
Eddie WaltEddie Walt
19:44 12 Jul 22
During a time in which competent, professional service at a fair price seems to have disappeared, Mr. Nemeth and his team are a refreshing breath of fresh air.From my first phone call to the final settlement of our case with a non-responsive IRS, they under-promised, over-delivered and were in constant courteous contact to make sure we knew exactly what was happening and where we stood.I hope to never need their services again, but, should I receive another friendly letter from the IRS...I know who to call!
Quick Inquiry


    Enter the text you see above