Understanding Tax Fraud: Key Types, Penalties, & Differences from Tax Evasion

Every year, thousands of taxpayers unknowingly put themselves at risk of being investigated by the IRS – not always because of malice, but due to misunderstandings about tax rules or blind trust in unreliable preparers. But not all errors are equal. When mistakes cross the line into tax fraud, the consequences can be life-altering – ranging from audits and heavy fines to criminal charges and prison time.

What makes tax fraud particularly dangerous is how easily it can be overlooked. From understated income and inflated deductions to stolen tax IDs and fraudulent refund schemes, tax fraud can take many forms – some deliberate, others the result of poor advice or negligence. Even those simply trying to reduce their tax burden may unknowingly cross into illegal territory, confusing legal tax avoidance with unlawful tax evasion.

This guide breaks down what tax fraud really is, how it differs from tax evasion, the major types of tax crimes, and what the IRS looks for during investigations. Whether you’re filing returns, running a business, or suspecting fraud in your community, understanding the rules is the first step toward staying compliant – and protected.

What is Tax Fraud?

Tax fraud is the deliberate act of deceiving tax authorities by falsifying or omitting information on a tax return to avoid paying the correct amount of taxes. According to the IRS, tax fraud typically involves intentional wrongdoing – such as underreporting income, inflating deductions, hiding assets, or filing false returns. Unlike an honest mistake or filing error, tax fraud is considered a tax crime because it involves willful intent to defraud the government.

Examples of tax fraud include:

• Claiming deductions or credits you don’t qualify for
• Using a fake Social Security Number
• Failing to report all sources of income
• Filing false tax returns using stolen identities (IRS ID fraud)
• Preparing fraudulent returns for others

The IRS considers fraud a serious offence and has a dedicated Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CI) to identify and pursue such cases. If convicted, individuals can face hefty fines, civil penalties, and even imprisonment.

Tax Fraud vs. Tax Evasion

Although often used interchangeably, tax fraud and tax evasion are not the same. Both are serious offences under federal law, but they differ in intent and legal implications.

Tax fraud involves a wilful act to deceive the IRS or state tax authorities, such as submitting false information, using a fake identity, or claiming deductions you know you’re not entitled to. It’s an intentional attempt to defraud the system, and it carries criminal penalties.

Tax evasion, on the other hand, refers specifically to illegally avoiding tax liability by hiding income, underreporting earnings, or failing to file returns altogether. While all tax evasion can be a form of tax fraud, not all tax fraud is necessarily tax evasion. For example, filing a fraudulent return on behalf of someone else (like in identity theft or tax preparer scams) constitutes tax fraud but not necessarily personal tax evasion.

There’s also a legal form of tax reduction called tax avoidance, which involves using legitimate strategies to reduce your tax burden, such as claiming allowable deductions or investing in tax-saving instruments. However, when these strategies are manipulated or misrepresented to the IRS, they can easily cross into the territory of fraud or evasion.

Aspect	Tax Fraud	Tax Evasion
Intent	Willful deception	Willful concealment or omission
Examples	Filing false returns, ID theft	Not reporting income, hiding assets
Legal Status	Criminal offence	Criminal offence
IRS Response	Investigated by IRS-CI	Investigated by IRS-CI
Possible Outcome	Fines, imprisonment, civil & criminal penalties	Same as tax fraud

Understanding these distinctions is key to staying on the right side of the law and avoiding unintentional exposure to a tax crime.

Types of Tax Fraud

Tax fraud can take many forms and is committed by both individuals and businesses. It can also occur through third-party scams or fraud rings that manipulate the tax system for financial gain. Below is a breakdown of the most common types:

Tax Fraud by Individuals

Individual taxpayers may commit IRS tax fraud knowingly or through the help of unscrupulous preparers. Common examples include:

• Underreporting income (especially cash income from gig work or side jobs)
• Overstating deductions or credits, such as charitable donations or home office expenses
• Failing to file tax returns altogether
• Claiming dependents who don’t qualify
• Committing IRS ID fraud by filing a return using someone else’s identity to claim a fraudulent refund

Some individuals are also victims of tax scams, such as phishing schemes where fraudsters steal tax information and file fake returns.

Tax Fraud by Businesses

Business owners can also be involved in tax evasion and tax fraud, often through:

• Underreporting sales or revenue
• Inflating expenses to reduce taxable income
• Misclassifying employees as contractors to avoid payroll taxes
• Using multiple sets of books to hide financial activities
• Failing to remit collected payroll or sales taxes to the IRS

These forms of tax fraud not only violate federal tax laws but also place legitimate competitors at a disadvantage and harm public trust in the tax system.

Other Forms of Tax Fraud

There are broader forms of taxation scams and fraudulent activities that don’t neatly fall into individual or business categories:

• Tax preparer fraud: When a preparer knowingly submits false information on behalf of clients
• Back taxes scams: Fake calls or emails threatening arrest unless unpaid taxes are settled immediately
• Refund fraud rings: Organized groups that file thousands of fraudulent returns using stolen data
• Abuse of tax shelters: Using complex offshore accounts to hide income
• Fraud tax return filings by cybercriminals using stolen credentials

No matter the method, committing tax fraud is a federal offence, and the IRS is increasingly using advanced technology and cross-agency collaboration to identify and prosecute offenders.

How to Avoid Tax Fraud

Avoiding tax fraud starts with understanding your responsibilities as a taxpayer and being proactive about compliance. Whether you’re filing as an individual or managing a business, the following practices can help you stay on the right side of the law and avoid accidental involvement in a tax crime:

• File accurate and complete returns: Double-check all income sources, deductions, and credits. Omitting income or inflating figures – even unintentionally – can raise red flags.
• Use trusted tax preparers: Ensure your tax preparer is registered and has a valid Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN). Watch for signs of fraud, like promises of unusually large refunds or asking you to sign blank returns.
• Protect your tax ID: Guard your Social Security Number (SSN) and tax documents to avoid becoming a victim of IRS ID fraud or refund scams.
• Keep records: Maintain detailed financial records, including receipts, invoices, and bank statements, to support your return in case of an audit.
• Don’t fall for scams: Be cautious of emails, texts, or calls from impostors claiming to be from the IRS. The agency never demands immediate payment or asks for financial information via phone or email.
• Understand the difference between legal tax avoidance and illegal tax evasion. If you’re unsure, consult a professional tax fraud attorney to clarify the law and stay compliant.

Even well-meaning taxpayers can fall into legal trouble if they rely on poor advice or fail to understand evolving tax laws. Staying informed and cautious is your best defence against committing tax fraud.

How to Report Tax Fraud to the IRS

If you suspect someone is committing IRS tax fraud – whether it’s an individual, a business, or even a tax preparer – you have multiple avenues to report it. The IRS takes these reports seriously and offers ways to remain anonymous or receive compensation in some cases.

Submit a Confidential Tip

To report suspected tax fraud anonymously, complete Form 3949-A (Information Referral) and mail it to the IRS. You do not need to reveal your identity, but providing specific details – such as names, dates, and evidence – will increase the chance of action.

Mail to:
Internal Revenue Service
Fresno, CA 93888

Examples include unreported income, fraudulent deductions, or false tax return filings.

File a Whistleblower Claim

If your tip leads to the recovery of unpaid taxes, you may be eligible for a financial reward. The IRS Whistleblower Office handles cases where the amount in dispute exceeds $2 million. Use Form 211 (Application for Award for Original Information) to file your claim.

This programme is designed to encourage individuals – especially employees or insiders – to come forward with actionable information about tax evasion and tax fraud.

File a Complaint Against a Tax Preparer

If you suspect that a tax preparer is filing fraud tax returns or engaging in unethical practices, report them using Form 14157 (Complaint: Tax Return Preparer). If the preparer has altered your return without your knowledge, also file Form 14157-A.

Examples include inflated deductions, unauthorised changes, or refund theft.

Report Tax ID Theft

If someone has filed a return using your Social Security Number or business EIN, you may be a victim of IRS ID fraud. In this case:

• Complete Form 14039 (Identity Theft Affidavit)
• File your return by mail, along with proof of identity
• Contact the IRS Identity Protection Specialized Unit (IPSU)

Recognising the signs of tax ID theft early – such as receiving IRS letters for returns you didn’t file – can help you act quickly and minimize damage.

How Does the IRS Define Tax Fraud?

The IRS defines tax fraud as the willful act of cheating on a tax return to avoid paying the correct tax owed. Unlike honest mistakes or negligence, tax fraud involves an intent to deceive, which can include lying, falsifying documents, or concealing income or assets.

Common fraudulent behaviors include:

• Deliberately failing to file tax returns
• Falsifying income or deductions
• Using someone else’s identity to file a return
• Keeping two sets of books
• Making false claims for credits or exemptions

According to the IRS, indicators of fraud – also known as badges of fraud – may include consistently underreporting income, making false statements to IRS agents, or destroying financial records.

Once the IRS determines there is willful intent, the case may be referred to the IRS Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CI). Convictions may lead to both civil and criminal penalties, including imprisonment and significant fines.

How Does the IRS Uncover Tax Fraud?

The IRS uses a combination of advanced technology, human analysis, and whistleblower tips to detect potential tax fraud. While most returns are processed automatically, certain red flags can trigger further scrutiny or referral to the IRS Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CI).

Key methods used to uncover tax fraud include:

• Data matching: The IRS cross-checks information reported by taxpayers against W-2s, 1099s, and other third-party reports. Discrepancies often signal unreported income or fraudulent claims.
• Audit flags: Unusual deductions, inconsistent income patterns, or filing multiple returns under the same SSN can trigger a closer look.
• Whistleblower tips: Reports submitted through Form 3949-A or the Whistleblower Programme often lead to full investigations.
• Information from other agencies: The IRS collaborates with financial institutions, state tax authorities, and even international bodies to identify suspicious activity.
• Use of AI and analytics: The agency has increasingly adopted artificial intelligence tools to detect patterns of committing tax fraud across large datasets.

Once suspicious activity is confirmed, the IRS may initiate a civil audit or escalate the matter to criminal investigation, depending on the severity and evidence of intent. If tax fraud is confirmed, the IRS may impose severe tax evasion penalties, ranging from fines to imprisonment.

Possible Consequences of Tax Fraud

Committing tax fraud or tax evasion is not just a civil violation – it’s a federal crime that can lead to serious legal and financial consequences. Depending on the nature and extent of the fraud, penalties can be civil, criminal, or both.

1. Civil Penalties

The IRS may impose civil penalties even if criminal charges are not pursued. These include:

• Accuracy-related penalties (typically 20% of the underpayment)
• Civil fraud penalty, which can reach 75% of the underpaid tax due to fraud
• Interest charges on unpaid taxes

2. Criminal Penalties

Criminal convictions are reserved for the most serious or willful offences. Penalties include:

• Fines up to $250,000 for individuals (or $500,000 for corporations)
• Imprisonment up to 5 years per offence
• Restitution orders to repay the IRS

3. Long-Term Consequences

• Permanent criminal record
• Loss of business licenses or professional credentials
• Ineligibility for certain jobs or government contracts
• Ongoing scrutiny of tax filings

Even unintentional errors – such as hiring a fraudulent preparer or falling for taxation scams – can lead to audits and financial penalties. That’s why individuals facing investigation should seek legal counsel from a qualified tax fraud lawyer as early as possible.

Take Tax Fraud Seriously – Get the Right Legal Help

Whether you’re dealing with an IRS audit, facing allegations of committing tax fraud, or simply want to ensure your filings are compliant, the risks of mishandling tax matters are too high to ignore. Even minor errors can lead to serious consequences if perceived as intentional by the IRS. If you’re under investigation or suspect you may be at risk, don’t face the IRS alone.

The Law Offices of Nick Nemeth brings extensive experience in defending clients against tax-related investigations and penalties. Our team can help you navigate complex IRS procedures, build a strong defence, and protect your rights at every stage. From negotiating settlements to representing you in court, we provide the legal support you need. To discuss your requirements and consult tax attorneys in Dallas-Fort Worth, TX, call (972) 426-2553. Alternatively, you can also fill out our contact form, and our representative will reach out to you at the earliest.

Contact a trusted tax fraud attorney today to protect your finances, freedom, and future.

FAQs About Tax Fraud

1. Is tax fraud a big crime?

Yes. Tax fraud is a federal offence that can result in criminal prosecution, hefty fines, and prison time. The IRS treats it as a serious tax crime, especially when there is clear intent to deceive.

2. How does the IRS know if you cheated on your taxes?

The IRS uses data matching, audit triggers, whistleblower tips, and analytics to detect signs of tax fraud or tax evasion. Inconsistencies in reported income or suspicious deductions often prompt further investigation.

3. What triggers an IRS criminal investigation?

If you’re in Dallas, Fort Worth, or surrounding areas, an IRS investigation may be triggered by false returns, underreported income, or tips submitted through IRS fraud reporting tools. High-risk professions or repeated violations also raise red flags.

4. What are the penalties for committing tax fraud?

Penalties for tax fraud include civil fines of up to 75% of unpaid taxes and criminal penalties such as imprisonment (up to 5 years) and fines up to $250,000 for individuals.

5. Can tax fraud be accidental?

No. To qualify as tax fraud, there must be intent to deceive. Honest mistakes or negligence may lead to penalties, but usually don’t meet the legal threshold for fraud.

6. What is the difference between civil and criminal tax fraud?

Civil tax fraud results in monetary penalties, while criminal tax fraud can lead to prosecution, imprisonment, and a permanent criminal record. The IRS may pursue either or both, depending on the case.

7. What should I do if I suspect someone of tax fraud near me?

You can report them using IRS Form 3949-A. If you’re in Texas, submitting the form by mail to the IRS office or consulting a tax fraud lawyer for guidance can help ensure your tip is handled correctly.

8. Can I go to jail for tax fraud?

Yes. If convicted of IRS tax fraud, you could face federal prison time – up to 5 years per offence – depending on the severity and your intent.

9. How can I avoid committing tax fraud unintentionally?

File accurate returns, use a reputable preparer, and stay informed about tax rules. When in doubt, consult a tax fraud attorney to ensure compliance and avoid unintentional tax evasion.

10. Is tax fraud a federal or state crime?

Tax fraud can be both. Most cases are handled by the IRS at the federal level, but you may also face state charges if you defraud your local revenue department.

11. Can hiring a bad tax preparer get me in trouble for fraud?

Yes. If a preparer files a fraud tax return on your behalf, you may still be held responsible unless you can prove you were unaware. Always vet your preparer thoroughly.

12. What is the IRS Criminal Investigation Division (IRS-CI)?

IRS-CI is the agency’s law enforcement arm that investigates complex cases of tax fraud, money laundering, and financial crimes. They’re responsible for building criminal cases and recommending prosecutions.

13. How can the Law Offices of Nick Nemeth help if I’m being investigated for tax fraud?

If you’re facing a tax fraud investigation in Dallas or surrounding areas, The Law Offices of Nick Nemeth can help you respond to IRS notices, build a legal defence, negotiate settlements, and avoid harsh penalties.

Reviewed and Verified By

Please follow and like us: